FAIR VALUE REPORT

REALTY INCOME · O · NOV 06, 2026 · AFTER RESULTS OF NOV 02, 2026

Wall Street trimmed Realty Income to $65 after a raised forecast. The model sees $75

The 2 November results beat and lifted the cash forecast, yet two banks cut their targets within days. The share price is tracking the 10-year Treasury, not the rent roll - and that is the gap between $65 and $75.

FPI VERDICT · NOV 06, 2026

DCF 50% · RELATIVE 30% · CONSENSUS 20%

26.4%

below fair value

PRICE AT PUBLICATION$59.50
FPI FAIR VALUE$75.23
WALL STREET TARGET$64.16

UNCERTAINTY

LOW ±10%

FAIR VALUE BAND

$67.71 – $82.75

PRICE VS BAND

BELOW THE BAND

Numbers as of publication. Today's fair value and price: O stock page → · How uncertainty is rated →

5 MIN READ

THE REPORT IN 3 POINTS

  • 01Realty Income's $0.43 Q3 EPS beat included $113.9m of property-sale gains, about $0.12 per share; underlying was near $0.31
  • 02FPI's fair value is $75.23 versus the $59.50 price and a $65 analyst median, with 18 of 34 analysts on hold
  • 03About $2.9bn of 2.9% debt matures in 2027, and refinancing 2.5 points higher would cost roughly $0.08 per share a year

The first beat in two years rode on $113.9 million of building sales

Realty Income ($O) reported earnings of $0.43 per share for the quarter to September 2026 against a $0.41 estimate - the first beat after four straight misses. The cleaner number is thinner. Gains on property sales were $113.9 million, up from $49.1 million a year earlier, and on 948.8 million shares they alone contributed $0.12. Strip them out and the quarter earned about $0.31, roughly where the comparable quarter of 2025 stood without its own gains.

Net income guidance for 2026 was cut to $1.55-1.56 from $1.59-1.60, while the cash measure that pays the dividend, AFFO (adjusted funds from operations - rental cash flow after non-cash accounting items), moved up a single cent to $4.45-4.46. Impairments rose 48% to $111.6 million. AFFO per share grew 3.7% to $1.12 while total AFFO grew 7.0%: the 3.3-point gap is 31 million new shares issued to fund growth.

The 13% revenue beat has a similar footnote. Interest income from loans and preferred equity doubled to $105.0 million as the loan book grew to $5.03 billion from $3.27 billion at 31 December 2025. Lending at a 7.9% yield is more profitable than buying buildings at 6.8%, and nine-month credit-loss provisions of $60.6 million (vs $31.9 million) are the cost of that trade. For a REIT, the P/E of 57.6x is noise from depreciation; the right lens is price to AFFO, and at $59.50 that is 13.4x.

RESULTS VS ESTIMATES · LAST 8 QUARTERS
REPORTEDEPSVS EST.PRICE REACTION
NOV 02, 2026$0.43+4.9%−0.1%
AUG 05, 2026$0.37−7.5%−0.5%
MAY 06, 2026$0.33−17.5%−3.5%
FEB 24, 2026$0.32−15.8%−0.8%
NOV 03, 2025$0.35−12.5%+0.4%
AUG 04, 2025$0.22−45.0%+1.6%
MAY 05, 2025$0.28−22.2%0.0%
FEB 24, 2025$1.05−0.9%−1.5%

Realty Income beat the EPS estimate in 1 of the last 8 quarters. Price reaction is the move on the trading day after the results.

A 0.72-point Treasury swing moved the stock $6 - and the targets with it

The 10-year Treasury yield was 4.63% on 5 August 2026, peaked at 5.35% on 5 October and was back near 4.9% on 2 November, per figures given on the results call. The share price traced that curve: a 52-week low of $53.15 in the spike, then a 9.7% rebound in a month while the S&P 500 fell 5.9%. For a stock yielding 5.46%, a bond yield above 5% is direct competition.

The target cuts clustered inside the spike, not after the results: Scotiabank downgraded to sector perform on 24 September, Wells Fargo went from $64 to $59 on 19 October and Barclays from $65 to $61 on 20 October. The real exposure is a date: about $2.9 billion of debt at 2.9% matures in 2027, including 1.875% notes due January and 1.125% notes due July. Interest expense already rose 13.3% to $333.6 million in the quarter. Refinancing 2.5 points higher would cost about $72 million a year - roughly $0.08 per share, or 1.7% of 2026 AFFO. Euro 10-year debt, about 0.8 points cheaper than dollar debt, is the main offset.

Why the model pays 16.9x cash flow for a stock the market prices at 13.4x

The FPI fair value is $75.23, a 26.4% gap to the $59.50 price. At the 2026 AFFO midpoint of $4.455, the price is 13.4x cash flow and the fair value 16.9x. The DCF half of the model is lifted by inputs that look like a bond with escalators: 98.8% occupancy across 15,536 properties, a 103.5% rent recapture rate on expiring leases, 8.5 years of weighted average remaining lease term, a 72.6% AFFO payout and 20 years of dividend growth. The quarter's $2.2 billion of pro-rata investment at a 6.8% yield against a blended cost of capital of about 5% - a 1.7-point spread - is what a DCF compounds over a long horizon.

The peer leg pulls the other way. A P/E of 57.6x against an industry median of 12.7x and a return on invested capital of 1.6% against 4.9% both look terrible, but both are distorted by $647.6 million of quarterly depreciation on buildings that are not losing value. EV/EBITDA (company value including debt, divided by operating earnings before depreciation) of 12.3x against an industry median of 13.8x and a dividend yield of 5.46% against 4.67% say the opposite. The company's own marks sit between the two camps: it sold equity at $60.49, has 18.5 million forward shares at $60.61, and in August bought back about 3 million shares for $188.7 million while buying a convertible cap at $83.55.

PRICE VS FPI FAIR VALUE · 120 DAYS TO PUBLICATIONPRICEFAIR VALUE
$82.55$66.87$51.19
JUL 9NOV 6

Over the 120 days to November 6, 2026 the share price went from $63.19 to $59.06 (−6.5%) and the FPI fair value from $63.70 to $75.23 (+18.1%). The gap moved from 0.8% below fair value to 27.4% below.

Street vs model: $65 against $75.23, with 18 of 34 analysts on hold

The Wall Street consensus on 6 November 2026 is hold: 0 strong buy, 13 buy, 18 hold, 3 sell. Targets as of 19 October run from $59 to $69, with a median of $65 and a mean of $64.16. The median is 13.6% below the FPI fair value and only 9.2% above the price. Post-results moves went the same way as the pre-results cuts: BNP Paribas trimmed to $64 from $69 on 3 November and Cantor Fitzgerald to $63 from $68 on 5 November. The one-month target average of $92.69 is skewed by one outlier and is ignored here.

The gap has a mechanism. Analysts set 12-month targets off a P/AFFO multiple anchored to the current 10-year yield - at 14-15x, $4.46 of AFFO gives $62-67, which is the whole target range. A DCF discounts 8.5-year leases over decades and barely notices a 31-day Treasury move. Both sides read the same portfolio; they differ on how long a 4.9% Treasury lasts.

WALL STREET PRICE TARGETS · 34 ANALYSTS
LOW $59.00HIGH $69.00
PRICE $59.50
FPI $75.23

13 buy · 18 hold · 3 sell. FPI fair value sits 9% above the highest Street target, the share price is inside the range.

Three numbers decide whether $59.50 becomes $65 or $75: 4.9%, $2.9 billion, $4.60

Up case: the 10-year yield drifts back under 4.5% and the 2027 AFFO guidance due with the next results on 23 February 2027 lands at $4.60 or above (3.4% growth). That would support the Street's $65-69 on its own multiple and move the price toward the model's $75 as refinancing fear fades.

Down case: the Treasury revisits its 5.35% October peak, the $2.9 billion of 2027 maturities reprices at 2.5 points more, or credit losses overshoot the 0.3%-of-rent guide (cut from 0.4% on 2 November) as the $5.03 billion loan book seasons.

Signals to watch:

  • The 200-day average of $61.57, 3.5% above the price, and the 52-week low of $53.15 as the two edges of the current range.
  • Fourth-quarter 2026 investment volume: $2.1 billion is needed to complete the $10.0 billion target with a spread still near 1.7 points.
  • Results on 23 February 2027, EPS estimate $0.42: the first quarter in which 2027 refinancing costs enter guidance.
BULLS SAY · BEARS SAY
BULL CASE$82.75+39%

TOP OF THE FPI FAIR VALUE BAND

  • 01A 10-year Treasury drift back under 4.5% would re-rate a 5.46% yielder whose price already rebounded 9.7% in the month to 5 November 2026.
  • 022027 AFFO guidance of $4.60 or above at the 23 February 2027 results would mark 3.4% growth and push the multiple from 13.4x toward the model's 16.9x.
  • 03Investing $2.1 billion in the fourth quarter of 2026 to hit the $10.0 billion target at a 1.7-point spread over a 5% cost of capital is what the DCF compounds.
BEAR CASE$59.00−1%

LOWEST WALL STREET TARGET

  • 01Earnings of $0.43 included $113.9 million of property-sale gains worth $0.12 a share, leaving about $0.31 underlying, flat on the comparable 2025 quarter.
  • 02About $2.9 billion of 2027 maturities carrying 2.9% coupons repricing 2.5 points higher would cost roughly $72 million a year, some 1.7% of 2026 AFFO.
  • 03The $5.03 billion loan book, up from $3.27 billion at 31 December 2025, already carries $60.6 million of nine-month credit-loss provisions versus $31.9 million.

FPI FAIR VALUE $75.23 · FPI fair value of $75.23 sits far above the $59.00 low target and near the $82.75 band top, because the DCF weighs 98.8% occupancy and a 1.7-point investment spread over a 31-day Treasury move.

FPI fair value blends a discounted cash flow model (50%), relative valuation against sector peers (30%) and analyst consensus (20%), updated daily. How the model works →

TRACK THE NUMBER

Get notified when O's fair value changes

Set your own buy price for O and the app alerts you when the stock reaches it. iOS and Android.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

MORE O REPORTS

This is the first FPI fair value report on Realty Income. The next one follows the company's next quarterly results.

MORE REPORTS IN REAL ESTATE

Fair Price Index is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Fair value calculations are model-based estimates and may not reflect actual market conditions. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.