FAIR VALUE REPORT
REALTY INCOME · O · NOV 06, 2026 · AFTER RESULTS OF NOV 02, 2026
Wall Street trimmed Realty Income to $65 after a raised forecast. The model sees $75
The 2 November results beat and lifted the cash forecast, yet two banks cut their targets within days. The share price is tracking the 10-year Treasury, not the rent roll - and that is the gap between $65 and $75.
FPI VERDICT · NOV 06, 2026
DCF 50% · RELATIVE 30% · CONSENSUS 20%
26.4%
below fair value
UNCERTAINTY
LOW ±10%
FAIR VALUE BAND
$67.71 – $82.75
PRICE VS BAND
BELOW THE BAND
Numbers as of publication. Today's fair value and price: O stock page → · How uncertainty is rated →
5 MIN READ
THE REPORT IN 3 POINTS
- 01Realty Income's $0.43 Q3 EPS beat included $113.9m of property-sale gains, about $0.12 per share; underlying was near $0.31
- 02FPI's fair value is $75.23 versus the $59.50 price and a $65 analyst median, with 18 of 34 analysts on hold
- 03About $2.9bn of 2.9% debt matures in 2027, and refinancing 2.5 points higher would cost roughly $0.08 per share a year
The first beat in two years rode on $113.9 million of building sales
Realty Income ($O) reported earnings of $0.43 per share for the quarter to September 2026 against a $0.41 estimate - the first beat after four straight misses. The cleaner number is thinner. Gains on property sales were $113.9 million, up from $49.1 million a year earlier, and on 948.8 million shares they alone contributed $0.12. Strip them out and the quarter earned about $0.31, roughly where the comparable quarter of 2025 stood without its own gains.
Net income guidance for 2026 was cut to $1.55-1.56 from $1.59-1.60, while the cash measure that pays the dividend, AFFO (adjusted funds from operations - rental cash flow after non-cash accounting items), moved up a single cent to $4.45-4.46. Impairments rose 48% to $111.6 million. AFFO per share grew 3.7% to $1.12 while total AFFO grew 7.0%: the 3.3-point gap is 31 million new shares issued to fund growth.
The 13% revenue beat has a similar footnote. Interest income from loans and preferred equity doubled to $105.0 million as the loan book grew to $5.03 billion from $3.27 billion at 31 December 2025. Lending at a 7.9% yield is more profitable than buying buildings at 6.8%, and nine-month credit-loss provisions of $60.6 million (vs $31.9 million) are the cost of that trade. For a REIT, the P/E of 57.6x is noise from depreciation; the right lens is price to AFFO, and at $59.50 that is 13.4x.
| REPORTED | REVENUE | VS EST. | EPS | VS EST. | PRICE REACTION |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NOV 02, 2026 | $1.6B | +13.3% | $0.43 | +4.9% | −0.1% |
| AUG 05, 2026 | $1.4B | +1.5% | $0.37 | −7.5% | −0.5% |
| MAY 06, 2026 | $1.4B | +3.3% | $0.33 | −17.5% | −3.5% |
| FEB 24, 2026 | $1.4B | +2.8% | $0.32 | −15.8% | −0.8% |
| NOV 03, 2025 | $1.5B | +5.5% | $0.35 | −12.5% | +0.4% |
| AUG 04, 2025 | $1.4B | +5.4% | $0.22 | −45.0% | +1.6% |
| MAY 05, 2025 | $1.4B | +4.9% | $0.28 | −22.2% | 0.0% |
| FEB 24, 2025 | $1.3B | +4.5% | $1.05 | −0.9% | −1.5% |
Realty Income beat the EPS estimate in 1 of the last 8 quarters. Price reaction is the move on the trading day after the results.
A 0.72-point Treasury swing moved the stock $6 - and the targets with it
The 10-year Treasury yield was 4.63% on 5 August 2026, peaked at 5.35% on 5 October and was back near 4.9% on 2 November, per figures given on the results call. The share price traced that curve: a 52-week low of $53.15 in the spike, then a 9.7% rebound in a month while the S&P 500 fell 5.9%. For a stock yielding 5.46%, a bond yield above 5% is direct competition.
The target cuts clustered inside the spike, not after the results: Scotiabank downgraded to sector perform on 24 September, Wells Fargo went from $64 to $59 on 19 October and Barclays from $65 to $61 on 20 October. The real exposure is a date: about $2.9 billion of debt at 2.9% matures in 2027, including 1.875% notes due January and 1.125% notes due July. Interest expense already rose 13.3% to $333.6 million in the quarter. Refinancing 2.5 points higher would cost about $72 million a year - roughly $0.08 per share, or 1.7% of 2026 AFFO. Euro 10-year debt, about 0.8 points cheaper than dollar debt, is the main offset.
Why the model pays 16.9x cash flow for a stock the market prices at 13.4x
The FPI fair value is $75.23, a 26.4% gap to the $59.50 price. At the 2026 AFFO midpoint of $4.455, the price is 13.4x cash flow and the fair value 16.9x. The DCF half of the model is lifted by inputs that look like a bond with escalators: 98.8% occupancy across 15,536 properties, a 103.5% rent recapture rate on expiring leases, 8.5 years of weighted average remaining lease term, a 72.6% AFFO payout and 20 years of dividend growth. The quarter's $2.2 billion of pro-rata investment at a 6.8% yield against a blended cost of capital of about 5% - a 1.7-point spread - is what a DCF compounds over a long horizon.
The peer leg pulls the other way. A P/E of 57.6x against an industry median of 12.7x and a return on invested capital of 1.6% against 4.9% both look terrible, but both are distorted by $647.6 million of quarterly depreciation on buildings that are not losing value. EV/EBITDA (company value including debt, divided by operating earnings before depreciation) of 12.3x against an industry median of 13.8x and a dividend yield of 5.46% against 4.67% say the opposite. The company's own marks sit between the two camps: it sold equity at $60.49, has 18.5 million forward shares at $60.61, and in August bought back about 3 million shares for $188.7 million while buying a convertible cap at $83.55.
Over the 120 days to November 6, 2026 the share price went from $63.19 to $59.06 (−6.5%) and the FPI fair value from $63.70 to $75.23 (+18.1%). The gap moved from 0.8% below fair value to 27.4% below.
Street vs model: $65 against $75.23, with 18 of 34 analysts on hold
The Wall Street consensus on 6 November 2026 is hold: 0 strong buy, 13 buy, 18 hold, 3 sell. Targets as of 19 October run from $59 to $69, with a median of $65 and a mean of $64.16. The median is 13.6% below the FPI fair value and only 9.2% above the price. Post-results moves went the same way as the pre-results cuts: BNP Paribas trimmed to $64 from $69 on 3 November and Cantor Fitzgerald to $63 from $68 on 5 November. The one-month target average of $92.69 is skewed by one outlier and is ignored here.
The gap has a mechanism. Analysts set 12-month targets off a P/AFFO multiple anchored to the current 10-year yield - at 14-15x, $4.46 of AFFO gives $62-67, which is the whole target range. A DCF discounts 8.5-year leases over decades and barely notices a 31-day Treasury move. Both sides read the same portfolio; they differ on how long a 4.9% Treasury lasts.
13 buy · 18 hold · 3 sell. FPI fair value sits 9% above the highest Street target, the share price is inside the range.
Three numbers decide whether $59.50 becomes $65 or $75: 4.9%, $2.9 billion, $4.60
Up case: the 10-year yield drifts back under 4.5% and the 2027 AFFO guidance due with the next results on 23 February 2027 lands at $4.60 or above (3.4% growth). That would support the Street's $65-69 on its own multiple and move the price toward the model's $75 as refinancing fear fades.
Down case: the Treasury revisits its 5.35% October peak, the $2.9 billion of 2027 maturities reprices at 2.5 points more, or credit losses overshoot the 0.3%-of-rent guide (cut from 0.4% on 2 November) as the $5.03 billion loan book seasons.
Signals to watch:
- The 200-day average of $61.57, 3.5% above the price, and the 52-week low of $53.15 as the two edges of the current range.
- Fourth-quarter 2026 investment volume: $2.1 billion is needed to complete the $10.0 billion target with a spread still near 1.7 points.
- Results on 23 February 2027, EPS estimate $0.42: the first quarter in which 2027 refinancing costs enter guidance.
TOP OF THE FPI FAIR VALUE BAND
- 01A 10-year Treasury drift back under 4.5% would re-rate a 5.46% yielder whose price already rebounded 9.7% in the month to 5 November 2026.
- 022027 AFFO guidance of $4.60 or above at the 23 February 2027 results would mark 3.4% growth and push the multiple from 13.4x toward the model's 16.9x.
- 03Investing $2.1 billion in the fourth quarter of 2026 to hit the $10.0 billion target at a 1.7-point spread over a 5% cost of capital is what the DCF compounds.
LOWEST WALL STREET TARGET
- 01Earnings of $0.43 included $113.9 million of property-sale gains worth $0.12 a share, leaving about $0.31 underlying, flat on the comparable 2025 quarter.
- 02About $2.9 billion of 2027 maturities carrying 2.9% coupons repricing 2.5 points higher would cost roughly $72 million a year, some 1.7% of 2026 AFFO.
- 03The $5.03 billion loan book, up from $3.27 billion at 31 December 2025, already carries $60.6 million of nine-month credit-loss provisions versus $31.9 million.
FPI FAIR VALUE $75.23 · FPI fair value of $75.23 sits far above the $59.00 low target and near the $82.75 band top, because the DCF weighs 98.8% occupancy and a 1.7-point investment spread over a 31-day Treasury move.
FPI fair value blends a discounted cash flow model (50%), relative valuation against sector peers (30%) and analyst consensus (20%), updated daily. How the model works →
TRACK THE NUMBER
Get notified when O's fair value changes
Set your own buy price for O and the app alerts you when the stock reaches it. iOS and Android.
MORE O REPORTS
This is the first FPI fair value report on Realty Income. The next one follows the company's next quarterly results.
MORE REPORTS IN REAL ESTATE
- VICI · Who is right about VICI: the $2 billion buyback or the $458 million loss reserve?OCT 30, 2026
- WPC · W. P. Carey's dividend now beats Treasuries by one point. Is that enough to own it?OCT 28, 2026
- NLY · Annaly hedged 100% and still lost 11% of its book. What does the 16% yield pay for?OCT 21, 2026
- AGNC · Is AGNC worth $13.83 when its own balance sheet says $7.13?OCT 20, 2026
Fair Price Index is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Fair value calculations are model-based estimates and may not reflect actual market conditions. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.





