FAIR VALUE REPORT

TARGET · TGT · NOV 18, 2026 · AFTER RESULTS OF NOV 18, 2026

Is Target still cheap once the $994 million refund leaves the earnings?

Target trades at 16.5 times earnings after an 80% rally. A one-off tariff refund sits inside that denominator. Without it the stock costs 20 times, and the model says $123.

FPI VERDICT · NOV 18, 2026

DCF 50% · RELATIVE 30% · CONSENSUS 20%

22.9%

above fair value

PRICE AT PUBLICATION$159.50
FPI FAIR VALUE$123.01
WALL STREET TARGET$166.95

UNCERTAINTY

HIGH ±35%

FAIR VALUE BAND

$79.96 – $166.07

PRICE VS BAND

INSIDE THE BAND

Numbers as of publication. Today's fair value and price: TGT stock page → · How uncertainty is rated →

5 MIN READ

THE REPORT IN 3 POINTS

  • 01Target's 16.5x earnings multiple includes a one-off $994 million tariff refund; without it the stock trades near 20x.
  • 02FPI fair value is $123.01, so the $159.50 share price sits 22.9% above it and 37% below the $168 analyst median.
  • 03Insiders sold $26.0 million across nine trades in twelve months with no purchases, and buybacks fell to $3 million.

16.5 times earnings, with $1.65 of customs money inside

Target ($TGT) went into its third-quarter report on 18 November 2026 looking like the cheapest big retailer on the Street: 16.5x trailing earnings against a Discount Stores median of 23.7x. The quarter to 1 November 2026 is the first one since the tariff refund, and the Street expected EPS of $2.07 on revenue of $26.56 billion, up from $1.78 and $25.3 billion in the same quarter of 2025, with comparable sales growth of roughly 3-5%. The base is soft: in the quarter to 1 November 2025 comps fell 2.7%.

The denominator of that 16.5x is the problem. In the quarter to 1 August 2026, Target booked $994 million of refunded IEEPA tariffs as a reduction of cost of sales. That lifted EPS to $4.11, of which $1.65 was the refund; without it, EPS rose 20% to $2.46. At $159.50 and 16.5x, trailing earnings work out at about $9.67 a share. Take out $1.65 and the stock trades at roughly 20x - the multiple of a growing retailer, not a bargain.

The same arithmetic applies to guidance. The $9.90-10.90 EPS range for 2026 issued on 19 August 2026 becomes $8.25-9.25 without the refund, and the operating margin of about 6% becomes about 5.1% once the 0.9 percentage points of customs money are removed. The ex-refund midpoint of $8.75 is still 16% above the $7.57 adjusted EPS of 2025 - real progress, priced at 18x rather than 16.5x.

RESULTS VS ESTIMATES · LAST 8 QUARTERS
REPORTEDEPSVS EST.PRICE REACTION
AUG 19, 2026$4.11+74.9%+4.3%
MAY 20, 2026$1.71+16.3%−3.9%
MAR 03, 2026$2.44+13.0%+6.7%
NOV 19, 2025$1.78+4.1%−2.8%
AUG 20, 2025$2.05+0.5%−6.3%
MAY 21, 2025$1.30−16.7%−5.2%
MAR 04, 2025$2.41+6.2%−3.5%
NOV 20, 2024$1.85−19.6%−22.1%

Target beat the EPS estimate in 6 of the last 8 quarters. Price reaction is the move on the trading day after the results.

Why the model stops at $123 when the price is $159.50

The FPI fair value is $123.01. The shares trade 22.9% above it, and the fair value sits 10% below even the 200-day average of $137.24. The peer leg of the model pulls the number up: at 16.5x earnings and 9.3x EV/EBITDA (enterprise value to operating profit before depreciation), Target is cheaper than the industry medians of 23.7x and 13.3x, and a 6.28% free cash flow yield (cash left after capex, divided by market cap) is nearly double the 3.65% industry median.

The discounted cash flow leg pulls the other way, and it carries half the weight. Revenue shrank 1.3% a year over three years; 2025 net sales of $104.8 billion were 1.7% below 2024. Return on invested capital of 11.3% trails the industry's 12.7%. Capex in the quarter to 1 August 2026 was $1.4 billion, up 27%, and $2.40 billion in six months against $1.86 billion a year earlier. Operating cash flow of $4.52 billion in those six months, against $2.36 billion a year earlier, looks like a cash machine until the refund is subtracted. A DCF prices the next decade of cash, and the accounts show flat sales and rising investment.

The valuation history shows what the rally actually bought. On 31 January 2026 the stock was $105.47 at 13.0x, which implies trailing earnings of about $8.11. Today's ex-refund trailing figure is about $8.02. The price rose 51% in ten months; the underlying earnings did not move. The whole gain is a re-rating, from 13x to 20x on earnings without the refund.

PRICE VS FPI FAIR VALUE · 120 DAYS TO PUBLICATIONPRICEFAIR VALUE
$176.02$131.63$87.24
JUL 21NOV 18

Over the 120 days to November 18, 2026 the share price went from $138.49 to $165.93 (+19.8%) and the FPI fair value from $98.26 to $123.01 (+25.2%). The gap moved from 29.0% above fair value to 25.9% above.

Street vs model: $168 against $123, a 37% gap

The consensus rating is buy, but the count is 28 buy, 28 hold, 4 sell - 32 of 60 analysts are not at buy. Price targets run from $140 to $200 with a median of $168 and a mean of $166.95. The median is 36.6% above the FPI fair value and 5.3% above the price; even the lowest target, $140, sits 13.8% above $123.01. The 19 targets issued in the last quarter average $167.21, 4.8% above $159.50: the Street is mostly saying the rally is done, not that it continues.

HSBC set $190 on 30 September 2026 with the stock at $156.45. Evercore ISI trimmed from $170 to $165 on 13 October 2026. Deutsche Bank has held $150 since 20 August 2026, and Jefferies reiterated its buy on 16 November 2026 without lifting the bar. Analysts capitalise the turnaround: comps of +5.6% with traffic +4.4% in the quarter to 2 May 2026, +3.8% with traffic +3.6% in the quarter to 1 August 2026, advertising revenue up 29% to $279 million. The model weighs three years of shrinking sales and a capex step-up more heavily than three quarters of traffic growth - that is the 37%.

WALL STREET PRICE TARGETS · 60 ANALYSTS
LOW $140.00HIGH $200.00
PRICE $159.50
FPI $123.01

28 buy · 28 hold · 4 sell. FPI fair value sits 12% below the lowest Street target, the share price is inside the range.

Insiders sold $26 million; the company bought back $3 million

Target repurchased no shares in the quarter to 1 August 2026 and $3 million in the six months to that date, against $258 million a year earlier, leaving $8.3 billion of authorisation untouched. Dividends cost $518 million a quarter, $1.16 a share, raised 1.8%, for a yield of 2.88%.

Insiders made nine sales worth $26.0 million in twelve months and zero purchases. Executive chair Brian Cornell sold 50,000 shares at $163.56 on 25 August 2026 ($8.2 million) and Melissa Kremer sold 15,500 at $169.96 on 24 August 2026 ($2.6 million). Both prices are above today's $159.50. The people with the most information declined to buy at a multiple the company's own buyback programme also declined to pay.

Three numbers that move $159.50 toward $168 or toward $123

Toward $168 and the $170.75 high of the last 52 weeks:

  • Holiday-quarter comps (quarter to 30 January 2027) above 3% against a base of -2.5% in the fourth quarter of 2025, with traffic still positive.
  • Ex-refund 2026 EPS landing at or above $9.25, the top of the clean range, which would take the forward multiple below 17x.
  • A restart of repurchases from the $8.3 billion authorisation.

Toward $137.24, the 200-day average, and then $123.01:

  • Comps falling back toward zero, where they were in the quarter to 1 November 2025.
  • Operating margin without customs money below 5.1%, the figure the 19 August 2026 guidance implies.
  • Advertising growth slowing from 29%, the one line that justifies a growth multiple.

At $159.50 the stock needs ex-refund earnings to keep growing about 16% a year to earn its 20x. One weak holiday quarter, and the discount to peers the bull case rests on turns back into the 22.9% premium to fair value the model already sees.

BULLS SAY · BEARS SAY
BULL CASE$200.00+25%

HIGHEST WALL STREET TARGET

  • 01Holiday-quarter comps above 3% against the -2.5% base of the fourth quarter of 2025, with traffic still positive, would validate the turnaround the Street is paying for.
  • 02Ex-refund 2026 EPS landing at or above $9.25, the top of the clean range, would pull the forward multiple below 17x against a peer median of 23.7x.
  • 03Restarting buybacks from the untouched $8.3 billion authorisation, after just $3 million repurchased in the six months to 1 August 2026, would signal management sees value here.
BEAR CASE$79.96−50%

BOTTOM OF THE FPI FAIR VALUE BAND

  • 01Strip out the $1.65 per share tariff refund and trailing EPS is about $8.02, so the stock trades near 20x, not the headline 16.5x.
  • 02Revenue has shrunk 1.3% a year over three years, with 2025 net sales of $104.8 billion down 1.7% from 2024, while capex rose 27% to $1.4 billion in the quarter to 1 August 2026.
  • 03Insiders sold $26.0 million across nine trades in twelve months with zero purchases, including Brian Cornell's 50,000 shares at $163.56 on 25 August 2026.

FPI FAIR VALUE $123.01 · FPI fair value of $123.01 sits far closer to the $79.96 bear anchor than to the $200.00 bull anchor, because the 51% rally since 31 January 2026 re-rated the stock from 13x to 20x without earnings growth.

FPI fair value blends a discounted cash flow model (50%), relative valuation against sector peers (30%) and analyst consensus (20%), updated daily. How the model works →

TRACK THE NUMBER

Get notified when TGT's fair value changes

Set your own buy price for TGT and the app alerts you when the stock reaches it. iOS and Android.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

MORE TGT REPORTS

This is the first FPI fair value report on Target. The next one follows the company's next quarterly results.

MORE REPORTS IN CONSUMER DEFENSIVE

Fair Price Index is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Fair value calculations are model-based estimates and may not reflect actual market conditions. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.