FAIR VALUE REPORT
AMAZON · AMZN · NOV 02, 2026 · AFTER RESULTS OF OCT 29, 2026
Is Amazon at 19x earnings a bargain, or is the P/E hiding a $42 billion cash hole?
Amazon has not been this cheap on earnings since 2021, yet the model says $240 is 31% too much. The quarter to September 2026 shows why both can be true at once - and what has to change before 4 February 2027.
FPI VERDICT · NOV 02, 2026
DCF 50% · RELATIVE 30% · CONSENSUS 20%
30.7%
above fair value
UNCERTAINTY
HIGH ±35%
FAIR VALUE BAND
$108.25 – $224.83
PRICE VS BAND
ABOVE THE BAND
Numbers as of publication. Today's fair value and price: AMZN stock page → · How uncertainty is rated →
5 MIN READ
THE REPORT IN 3 POINTS
- 01Amazon closed at $240.35 on 30 October 2026, 31% above the FPI fair value of $166.54.
- 02Free cash flow swung to a $42.4 billion outflow, and long-term debt rose to $173.1 billion by 30 September 2026.
- 03Wall Street's mean target of $333.42 is double the model's value, with the next results due 4 February 2027.
19x earnings for the first time since 2021 - and the model still says 31% too much
Amazon ($AMZN) closed at $240.35 on 30 October 2026, down 1.41% after its results for the quarter to 30 September 2026. The stock trades at 19.2x trailing earnings. In the FPI valuation history the multiple was 51.5x at the end of 2021, 39.7x at the end of 2024 and 32.2x at the end of 2025. It now sits below the specialty-retail median of 19.9x, the kind of multiple the market pays for a supermarket chain. The shares lost 11.5% in the three months to 30 October 2026. Yet the FPI fair value is $166.54, 30.7% below the price.
The quarter explains the puzzle. Earnings per share of $1.89 missed the $1.97 estimate because the quarter to September 2025 had included $9.5 billion of pre-tax gains on the Anthropic stake, which did not repeat. Other income over the nine months to September 2026 was $68.4 billion. Trailing net income of $134.8 billion exceeds trailing operating income of $104.4 billion, as the press release shows. A company normally keeps less after tax than it earns before it; here the reverse holds, so a large part of the earnings behind that 19x are paper gains on a private stake.
| REPORTED | REVENUE | VS EST. | EPS | VS EST. | PRICE REACTION |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OCT 29, 2026 | $202B | −0.1% | $1.89 | −4.1% | −1.4% |
| JUL 30, 2026 | $201B | +1.8% | $5.75 | +215.9% | +15.3% |
| APR 29, 2026 | $182B | +2.4% | $2.78 | +70.6% | +0.8% |
| FEB 05, 2026 | $213B | +0.9% | $1.95 | −1.0% | −5.6% |
| OCT 30, 2025 | $180B | +1.3% | $1.95 | +24.2% | +9.6% |
| JUL 31, 2025 | $168B | +3.7% | $1.68 | +28.2% | −8.3% |
| MAY 01, 2025 | $156B | +0.3% | $1.59 | +16.1% | −0.1% |
| FEB 06, 2025 | $188B | +0.2% | $1.86 | +24.8% | −3.0% |
Amazon beat the EPS estimate in 6 of the last 8 quarters. Price reaction is the move on the trading day after the results.
$107 billion of new debt in nine months: how the AI build is now paid for
Free cash flow - operating cash flow minus capital spending - swung from an inflow of $14.8 billion in the twelve months to September 2025 to an outflow of $42.4 billion in the twelve months to September 2026. Net purchases of property and equipment grew 82% to $210.7 billion. Cash capex in the quarter to September 2026 alone was $75.9 billion; management kept the 2026 figure at about $220 billion and expects meaningfully more in 2027.
The difference is borrowed. Long-term debt rose from $65.6 billion on 31 December 2025 to $173.1 billion on 30 September 2026, with $48.1 billion raised in the quarter alone, and quarterly interest expense tripled to $1.69 billion. A company that paid for its own growth through the decade to 2025 now has a lender in the room.
What the money buys is real. AWS sales of $46.0 billion grew 39%, operating profit was $17.8 billion at a 38.7% margin, and the backlog reached $578 billion. The rest slowed: online stores grew 2%, North America 6%, advertising 12% after 26% in the quarter to June 2026, partly because Prime Day moved into the second quarter. Guidance in the 8-K exhibit for the quarter to December 2026 is sales of $240.0-247.0 billion and operating income of $28.5-33.5 billion, against $25.0 billion in the quarter to December 2025.
Why the model lands at $166.54: a DCF cannot discount cash that is leaving
Half of the FPI fair value comes from a discounted cash flow model, which values a company on the cash it is expected to generate. Amazon's free cash flow yield is -1.81% - over the twelve months to September 2026 it consumed cash equal to 1.81% of its $2.59 trillion market value - against a specialty-retail median of +5.37%. A 16.9% net margin and a 26.7% return on equity are strong inputs, but a DCF starts from cash, and the cash number is negative.
The relative leg, 30% of the blend, gives no help. At 10.9x EV/EBITDA (enterprise value to operating profit before depreciation) and 19.2x earnings, Amazon sits on the retail medians of 10.1x and 19.9x, so peers award no premium. Only the consensus leg, at 20%, sits above the price.
Over the 119 days to November 2, 2026 the share price went from $244.16 to $245.63 (+0.6%) and the FPI fair value from $168.44 to $166.54 (−1.1%). The gap moved from 31.0% above fair value to 32.2% above.
Street vs model: Wall Street's $333 is exactly double the model's $166
The consensus rating is buy: 84 buy, 10 hold, 1 sell. The median target is $329.50, the mean is $333.42, the range $250 to $390. The mean sits 100% above the FPI fair value; even the lowest targets - D.A. Davidson and Raymond James at $250 on 30 October 2026 - are 50% above it.
The cuts of 30 October 2026 were small. Morgan Stanley went to $335 from $350, Goldman Sachs to $370 from $375 and Bank of America to $317 from $320, all with buy-equivalent ratings; Cantor Fitzgerald cut to $280 from $310 and Scotiabank to $300 from $325. Twelve targets issued in the month to 2 November 2026 average $329.08, above the $325.12 average of the seventeen issued over the quarter - targets rose while the share price fell.
The gap has a mechanism. The Street values forward operating profit from a $578 billion backlog and the 40%-plus AWS growth management projects for 2027 and 2028, and assumes capital spending normalises. The model's largest leg values the cash that exists in the twelve months to September 2026, and that cash leaves at $42.4 billion a year.
84 buy · 10 hold · 1 sell. FPI fair value sits 33% below the lowest Street target, the share price is below the whole range.
Three numbers to watch before 4 February 2027
For the stock to move toward the Street's $333, the cash statement has to catch up with the income statement: operating income for the quarter to December 2026 at the top of the $28.5-33.5 billion range, advertising back to high-teens growth as guided, AWS still above 40% into 2027, and trailing free cash flow less negative than -$42.4 billion.
For it to move toward the model's $166: a 2027 capex figure well above $220 billion without an AWS acceleration to match, an AWS margin below 35% as depreciation - already $20.9 billion in the quarter to September 2026, up from $16.8 billion in the quarter to September 2025 - catches up with the build, and another round of bond issuance.
Three levels frame the position:
- $243.40, the 200-day average, which the price now sits below; a recovery through it would be the first sign the slide has ended.
- $250, the floor of Street targets; a close below it would put the market beneath the most cautious bank.
- $196, the bottom of the 52-week range, and $166.54, the fair value, 15% below that range low.
Insiders made 126 sales worth $449.1 million and zero purchases in the twelve months to 2 November 2026. The next report, expected on 4 February 2027, carries a consensus of $2.42 in earnings per share on $244.66 billion of revenue, inside the $240-247 billion guide. The number that moves the fair value is the sign in front of free cash flow.
HIGHEST WALL STREET TARGET
- 01AWS sales of $46.0 billion grew 39% with a $578 billion backlog, and holding above 40% growth into 2027 is what underwrites a $390 target.
- 02Operating income guidance of $28.5-33.5 billion for the quarter to December 2026 compares with $25.0 billion a year earlier, so the top of the range marks real profit acceleration.
- 03The twelve targets issued in the month to 2 November 2026 average $329.08, above the $325.12 quarterly average, meaning banks raised estimates while the stock fell 11.5% in three months.
BOTTOM OF THE FPI FAIR VALUE BAND
- 01Free cash flow swung from an inflow of $14.8 billion to an outflow of $42.4 billion in the twelve months to September 2026, leaving a FCF yield of -1.81%.
- 02Long-term debt jumped from $65.6 billion on 31 December 2025 to $173.1 billion on 30 September 2026, and quarterly interest expense tripled to $1.69 billion.
- 03Trailing net income of $134.8 billion exceeds operating income of $104.4 billion because of one-off Anthropic gains, so the 19.2x multiple rests partly on paper profits.
FPI FAIR VALUE $166.54 · FPI fair value of $166.54 sits far closer to the $108.25 bear anchor than to the $390.00 bull anchor, because a DCF weighted 50% starts from cash, and cash left the business at $42.4 billion a year.
FPI fair value blends a discounted cash flow model (50%), relative valuation against sector peers (30%) and analyst consensus (20%), updated daily. How the model works →
TRACK THE NUMBER
Get notified when AMZN's fair value changes
Set your own buy price for AMZN and the app alerts you when the stock reaches it. iOS and Android.
MORE AMZN REPORTS
This is the first FPI fair value report on Amazon. The next one follows the company's next quarterly results.
MORE REPORTS IN CONSUMER CYCLICAL
- ABNB · Airbnb's bookings grew 21%. Its cash grew 6%. Is $187 running ahead of the money?NOV 11, 2026
- MCD · McDonald's rallied 20% on its first U.S. sales decline in six quarters. What did the buyers see?NOV 10, 2026
- RIVN · Wall Street and the model agree Rivian is worth $17. Who is selling it for $13?NOV 04, 2026
- SBUX · Starbucks hit its 2028 margin two years early. Is $104 already spending it?NOV 03, 2026
Fair Price Index is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Fair value calculations are model-based estimates and may not reflect actual market conditions. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.





