FAIR VALUE REPORT

MCDONALD'S · MCD · NOV 10, 2026 · AFTER RESULTS OF NOV 04, 2026

McDonald's rallied 20% on its first U.S. sales decline in six quarters. What did the buyers see?

U.S. sales fell, revenue missed and cash from operations dropped 12%, yet the shares jumped 6.5%. The stock looks cheap against its own history and 29.7% too expensive against the model. Both readings can be right.

FPI VERDICT · NOV 10, 2026

DCF 50% · RELATIVE 30% · CONSENSUS 20%

29.7%

above fair value

PRICE AT PUBLICATION$281.43
FPI FAIR VALUE$197.90
WALL STREET TARGET$282.79

UNCERTAINTY

LOW ±10%

FAIR VALUE BAND

$178.11 – $217.69

PRICE VS BAND

ABOVE THE BAND

Numbers as of publication. Today's fair value and price: MCD stock page → · How uncertainty is rated →

5 MIN READ

THE REPORT IN 3 POINTS

  • 01McDonald's rose 6.5% on 4 November 2026 despite U.S. comparable sales falling 0.2% and revenue missing estimates.
  • 02A $106 million gain from selling restaurants and property drove a third of the EPS rise, while operating cash fell 12%.
  • 03FPI fair value is $197.90 versus the $281.43 price, while Wall Street's median target sits at $285.

A 6.5% jump on a quarter that missed on sales

McDonald's $MCD reported the quarter to September 2026 on 4 November 2026 and the stock closed up 6.5%. Global comparable sales rose 1.5%, U.S. comparable sales fell 0.2% against +2.4% in the quarter to September 2025, and revenue grew 1% to $7.157 billion, below the $7.28 billion the Street expected. Adjusted earnings per share rose 11% to $3.57, beating the $3.38 estimate.

Buyers looked at direction, not level. Analysts had braced for U.S. comps of -0.5%, and U.S. sales turned positive in September after declines in July and August. Two value menus are in test, with the winner due across the U.S. in early 2027. That extended a rally from the $229.20 low of 7 October 2026: at $281.43 the stock is 22.8% above it, with an RSI of 76 (above 70 signals overbought) and the 200-day average of $282.21 directly overhead, yet still 17.5% below the $341.75 peak of 2 March 2026.

RESULTS VS ESTIMATES · LAST 8 QUARTERS
REPORTEDEPSVS EST.PRICE REACTION
NOV 04, 2026$3.57+5.6%+6.5%
AUG 04, 2026$3.38+1.8%+1.2%
MAY 07, 2026$2.83+3.3%−0.1%
FEB 11, 2026$3.12+2.3%−0.8%
NOV 05, 2025$3.22−3.3%+2.2%
AUG 06, 2025$3.19+1.6%+3.0%
MAY 01, 2025$2.67+0.4%−1.9%
FEB 10, 2025$2.83−0.7%+5.4%

McDonald's beat the EPS estimate in 6 of the last 8 quarters. Price reaction is the move on the trading day after the results.

$106 million of the beat came from selling restaurants and land, not burgers

Other operating income swung to $139 million from $37 million. Inside that line, gains on sales of restaurant businesses rose to $97 million from $35 million and sales of excess property swung to a $23 million gain from a $21 million loss. Together that is a $106 million pre-tax swing, roughly $0.12 per share after tax - about a third of the $0.35 year-on-year rise in adjusted EPS and over 40% of the $255 million rise in adjusted operating income. Selling a restaurant to a franchisee books a gain once.

Cash tells the same story. Third-quarter cash from operations fell 12% to $3.031 billion from $3.428 billion, and free cash flow (operating cash minus capital spending) fell 11% to $2.147 billion. Over the nine months to September 2026, dividends of $3.954 billion plus buybacks of $1.770 billion absorbed 98% of the $5.853 billion of free cash flow. The quarterly dividend still rose 4% to $1.93, the 50th consecutive annual increase, payable on 15 December 2026 - but the cushion under it is thinner than the share price suggests.

Why 22x earnings, the lowest since 2021, still lands 29.7% above fair value

The FPI fair value is $197.90, 29.7% below the $281.43 price. That looks odd next to a P/E of 22.1x, the lowest in six years of valuation history (every year-end from 2021 to 2025 printed between 25.4x and 31.6x) and below the restaurant-industry median of 25.1x. On its own past, McDonald's is cheap.

Against cash flow and peers it is not. Enterprise value to EBITDA (the price of the whole business, debt included, relative to operating cash earnings) is 17.2x against an industry median of 11.9x. The free cash flow yield of 3.76% - the cash generated each year per dollar of market value - is below the 4.27% industry median and the 6.06% sector median. A PEG ratio of 5.62x means investors pay more than five times the earnings growth rate. And $39.8 billion of long-term debt sits against shareholders' equity of -$343 million, which keeps enterprise value high in any discounted cash flow even as the share price falls. A 32.4% net margin and 17.7% return on invested capital justify a premium; with 3-year revenue growth of 5.1%, they struggle to justify a 45% premium to industry EV/EBITDA. The bull case rests on the Investor Day target of 23 September 2026 for an operating margin in the low-to-mid 50% range by 2030, up from 47.6% in the nine months to September 2026. A cash-flow model needs to see that in cash from operations, which just fell 12%.

PRICE VS FPI FAIR VALUE · 120 DAYS TO PUBLICATIONPRICEFAIR VALUE
$289.78$235.75$181.73
JUL 13NOV 10

Over the 120 days to November 10, 2026 the share price went from $274.60 to $282.33 (+2.8%) and the FPI fair value from $235.89 to $198.83 (−15.7%). The gap moved from 14.1% above fair value to 29.6% above.

Street vs model: $285 against $198, a 44% gap

Wall Street rates the stock a buy on 36 buy, 26 hold and 2 sell ratings. As of 5 November 2026 the price targets run from $230 to $325, with a median of $285 and a mean of $282.79. The 22 targets issued in the quarter to 10 November 2026 average $283.41 - within $2 of the current price. The Street itself sees the stock as fully valued.

Post-results moves show raised targets without upgraded ratings. On 5 November 2026 RBC Capital lifted its target to $300 while staying at Sector Perform, Bernstein moved to $280 from the $250 it set on 8 October 2026 while staying at Market Perform, and BTIG set $305 with a Buy. Even the lowest target on the Street is 16% above the FPI fair value; the median is 44% above it. The likely reason: analysts apply McDonald's historic 25x multiple to 2027 earnings and credit the 2030 margin target up front, while a model weighted 50% to cash flow and 30% to peers at 11.9x EV/EBITDA gives the debt and the 3.76% cash yield more say. Insiders have sided with the model: over the 12 months to 10 November 2026 they sold $36.6 million of stock in 21 transactions and bought none.

WALL STREET PRICE TARGETS · 64 ANALYSTS
LOW $230.00HIGH $325.00
PRICE $281.43
FPI $197.90

36 buy · 26 hold · 2 sell. FPI fair value sits 14% below the lowest Street target, the share price is inside the range.

Three numbers to watch before the 10 February 2027 report

The next results are expected on 10 February 2027 (not yet confirmed), with the Street at $3.20 of EPS - only 2.6% above the $3.12 reported for the quarter to December 2025.

  • U.S. comparable sales and guest counts for the quarter to December 2026. Positive traffic would validate the September turn and the early-2027 value-menu launch; another negative traffic quarter would mean growth is price, not people.
  • Cash from operations year on year. A second decline would undercut the 2030 margin story before it starts; 2026 guidance of free cash flow conversion in the low-to-mid 80% range and capital spending of about $3.7 billion are the benchmarks.
  • The price against two averages. Holding above the 200-day average of $282.21 would mark the recovery as more than a bounce; falling back through the 50-day average of $249.10 would reopen the path toward the $197.90 fair value.

Re-rating up needs the 2026 operating margin at the high end of the mid-to-high 40% range and a dividend covered with room to spare. Re-rating down needs nothing new: at 22x earnings and 17.2x EV/EBITDA, the stock already prices the margin target arriving on schedule.

BULLS SAY · BEARS SAY
BULL CASE$325.00+15%

HIGHEST WALL STREET TARGET

  • 01U.S. comparable sales turned positive in September 2026 after July and August declines, and a national value menu lands in early 2027 to hold that turn.
  • 02The Investor Day of 23 September 2026 targets a low-to-mid 50% operating margin by 2030, up from 47.6% in the nine months to September 2026.
  • 03At 22.1x earnings the stock is cheaper than any year-end from 2021 to 2025, which ranged from 25.4x to 31.6x, and below the 25.1x industry median.
BEAR CASE$178.11−37%

BOTTOM OF THE FPI FAIR VALUE BAND

  • 01About $106 million of pre-tax gains from selling restaurants and property, roughly $0.12 per share, drove a third of the $0.35 rise in adjusted EPS.
  • 02Third-quarter cash from operations fell 12% to $3.031 billion, and dividends plus buybacks absorbed 98% of nine-month free cash flow of $5.853 billion.
  • 03EV/EBITDA of 17.2x is 45% above the 11.9x industry median while three-year revenue growth is just 5.1% and long-term debt stands at $39.8 billion.

FPI FAIR VALUE $197.90 · FPI fair value of $197.90 sits far below both anchors and near the $178.11 band floor, because the quarter's earnings beat leaned on one-time asset sale gains while operating cash fell 12%.

FPI fair value blends a discounted cash flow model (50%), relative valuation against sector peers (30%) and analyst consensus (20%), updated daily. How the model works →

TRACK THE NUMBER

Get notified when MCD's fair value changes

Set your own buy price for MCD and the app alerts you when the stock reaches it. iOS and Android.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

MORE MCD REPORTS

This is the first FPI fair value report on McDonald's. The next one follows the company's next quarterly results.

MORE REPORTS IN CONSUMER CYCLICAL

Fair Price Index is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Fair value calculations are model-based estimates and may not reflect actual market conditions. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.