FAIR VALUE REPORT

SUPER MICRO COMPUTER · SMCI · NOV 09, 2026 · AFTER RESULTS OF NOV 03, 2026

Why does a 298% grower cost 5 times earnings?

Supermicro nearly quadrupled revenue to $19.9 billion and the shares ended the week at $28.76, 30.8% below the FPI fair value. The 5.2x P/E is real. So are the 44% customer, the cash burn and 136 million new shares waiting at $27.50.

FPI VERDICT · NOV 09, 2026

DCF 50% · RELATIVE 30% · CONSENSUS 20%

30.8%

below fair value

PRICE AT PUBLICATION$28.76
FPI FAIR VALUE$37.61
WALL STREET TARGET$42.33

UNCERTAINTY

VERY HIGH ±50%

FAIR VALUE BAND

$18.80 – $56.41

PRICE VS BAND

INSIDE THE BAND

Numbers as of publication. Today's fair value and price: SMCI stock page → · How uncertainty is rated →

5 MIN READ

THE REPORT IN 3 POINTS

  • 01Supermicro's revenue hit $19.9 billion in the quarter to 30 September 2026, but gross margin fell to 12.7% from 17.5%.
  • 02The stock closed at $28.76, 30.8% below the FPI fair value of $37.61, and trades at 5.2x trailing earnings.
  • 03One customer was 44% of sales, operations used $434 million of cash, and preferred stock can add 136 million shares below $27.50.

A $19.9 billion quarter that the market sold down to $27.08

Super Micro Computer ($SMCI) delivered the quarter its bulls had waited for. Net sales for the quarter to 30 September 2026 reached $19.9 billion, against $11.1 billion in the quarter to June 2026 and $5.0 billion in the quarter to September 2025. Net income was $1.59 billion, and the fiscal 2027 (to June 2027) revenue forecast rose to $72-82 billion from $65-72 billion.

The stock fell 5.7% to $29.60 on 4 November, another 8.5% to $27.08 on 5 November, then rebounded 6.2% to $28.76 on 6 November. Three details explain why a 298% growth quarter was sold. Gross margin was 12.7%, down from 17.5% a quarter earlier. One data center customer paid 44% of revenue, up from 28% for all of fiscal 2026. And about $2.3 billion was catch-up from deployments planned for earlier periods, so the underlying figure was closer to $17.6 billion.

The cash flow statement adds a fourth. While booking $1.59 billion of profit, the company used $434 million of cash in operations. On 30 September 2026 inventories stood at $15.05 billion and receivables at $9.69 billion, against $6.9 billion of cash and $8.6 billion of bank debt and convertible notes.

RESULTS VS ESTIMATES · LAST 8 QUARTERS
REPORTEDEPSVS EST.PRICE REACTION
NOV 03, 2026$1.81+41.4%−5.7%
AUG 11, 2026$1.70+84.8%+19.0%
MAY 05, 2026$0.84+35.5%+24.5%
FEB 03, 2026$0.69+40.8%+13.8%
NOV 04, 2025$0.35−5.4%−11.3%
AUG 05, 2025$0.41−8.9%−18.3%
MAY 06, 2025$0.31−24.4%−1.4%
FEB 25, 2025$0.51+8.5%−1.0%

Super Micro Computer beat the EPS estimate in 5 of the last 8 quarters. Price reaction is the move on the trading day after the results.

5.2x earnings on 659 million shares - and 136 million more waiting at $27.50

At $28.76 the stock trades at 5.2x trailing earnings, against a Computer Hardware industry median of 17.3x. A multiple that low usually belongs to a business expected to shrink, not one guiding to $77 billion of sales at the midpoint.

There were 659.2 million common shares at 30 September 2026, but the diluted count used for EPS was already 749.4 million. The difference is mostly the financing of 11 June 2026, when the company sold 45.5 million shares at $27.50 and $3.75 billion of 7% mandatory convertible preferred stock. That preferred converts by 1 June 2029 into 30.304 to 36.364 common shares per $1,000, a band of $27.50 to $33.00 a share. The lower the stock, the more shares it becomes: at or below $27.50 the conversion maxes out at about 136 million shares, roughly 20% of the common count. At $28.76 the stock sits $1.26 above that floor.

The preferred also costs about $75 million a quarter in dividends paid before common shareholders see anything. CEO Charles Liang and director Sara Liu each sold 100,000 shares at $40.00 on 4 September 2026 and again at $45.02 on 7 October 2026, $17 million in total, against no insider purchases in 12 months.

Fair value $37.61: peer multiples pull up, -$434 million of cash flow pulls down

The FPI fair value stands at $37.61, 30.8% above the $28.76 close and almost exactly on the stock's 50-day average of $37.44. The model blends a discounted cash flow at 50%, sector peers at 30% and analyst consensus at 20%, and here the three legs disagree.

The peer leg is generous: a P/S of 0.3x against an industry median of 1.4x and an EV/EBITDA of 4.3x against 12.2x mean the stock would nearly triple if it traded like an average hardware maker. The consensus leg, a mean target of $42.33, points the same way, and a return on invested capital of 17.2% against an industry 8.3% supports both.

The DCF leg is the problem. A discounted cash flow model values the cash a business actually produces, and Supermicro's free cash flow yield is -34.39%: in fiscal 2026 the company used $6.8 billion of operating cash on $39.1 billion of revenue. For a cash-burning company the DCF fair value is far less stable than for a cash generator, because it hinges on when $15 billion of inventory turns into dollars. That drag is why the blend lands at $37.61 rather than the $60-70 a peer multiple alone would imply.

PRICE VS FPI FAIR VALUE · 119 DAYS TO PUBLICATIONPRICEFAIR VALUE
$49.19$35.57$21.95
JUL 13NOV 9

Over the 119 days to November 9, 2026 the share price went from $28.31 to $28.60 (+1.0%) and the FPI fair value from $27.38 to $37.61 (+37.4%). The gap moved from 3.3% above fair value to 31.5% below.

Street vs model: $39 to $65 on Wall Street, $37.61 in the model

Of 28 analysts on 9 November 2026, 10 say buy, 15 hold and 3 sell: a consensus of hold. The median target is $42 and the mean $42.33 as of 4 November 2026, 12.5% above the FPI fair value and 47% above the price.

On 4 November 2026 Raymond James lifted its target to $65 from $48 and kept Outperform, and Oppenheimer upgraded to Outperform the same day. The same day Bank of America nudged its target to $39 from $38 and kept Underperform over margins and cash flow. Raymond James is 73% above the model; Bank of America is 4% above it.

The gap has a mechanism. The Street anchors on the earnings guide: $1.66-1.90 of non-GAAP EPS for the quarter to December 2026 annualises to about $7, making $28.76 roughly 4x forward earnings and $65 about 9x. The model gives half its weight to cash, and the cash side shows a fiscal 2027 gross margin guided to 11.8-12.2%, below the 12.7% just reported, and two customers holding 49% and 17% of receivables.

WALL STREET PRICE TARGETS · 28 ANALYSTS
LOW $36.00HIGH $48.00
PRICE $28.76
FPI $37.61

10 buy · 15 hold · 3 sell. FPI fair value sits inside the Street range, the share price is below the whole range.

Three numbers before 2 February 2027: 12% margin, 40% customer, $27.50

The next results are due on 2 February 2027; consensus expects EPS of $1.68 on revenue of $19.95 billion. Three readings decide how the 30.8% gap closes.

  • Gross margin at or above 12%. The guide for the quarter to December 2026 is 12-12.5%. Above 12.5% the fiscal 2027 range looks conservative; below 11.8% the second-half decline has started early.
  • Customer concentration below 40%, with positive operating cash flow. That would show the cash conversion cycle improvement from 149 to 97 days is structural, not a one-off from $3.1 billion of customer prepayments.
  • The $27.50 line, the June 2026 offering price and the preferred's conversion floor. The stock touched $25.81 on 5 November 2026. Above it, dilution shrinks with every dollar; below it, the share count is fixed to grow by 136 million.

A close above the 200-day average of $32.61 would be the first sign that the market is pricing the $77 billion midpoint rather than the 44% customer. A second-half quarter below the roughly $18 billion that midpoint implies would reopen the question of how much of the $19.9 billion was borrowed from the future.

BULLS SAY · BEARS SAY
BULL CASE$56.42+96%

TOP OF THE FPI FAIR VALUE BAND

  • 01A re-rating toward the Computer Hardware median EV/EBITDA of 12.2x from 4.3x, or P/S of 1.4x from 0.3x, alone implies a price well above the bull anchor.
  • 02Positive operating cash flow on 2 February 2027 would confirm the cash conversion cycle improvement from 149 to 97 days is structural and unlock the peer leg of the model.
BEAR CASE$18.81−35%

BOTTOM OF THE FPI FAIR VALUE BAND

  • 01Gross margin fell to 12.7% from 17.5% a quarter earlier and fiscal 2027 is guided to 11.8-12.2%, so profits shrink even as revenue grows.
  • 02The company used $434 million of cash in operations while booking $1.59 billion of profit, with $15.05 billion of inventory and $9.69 billion of receivables on 30 September 2026.
  • 03A close below $27.50 fixes the mandatory convertible at about 136 million extra shares, roughly 20% of the 659.2 million common count.

FPI FAIR VALUE $37.61 · FPI fair value of $37.61 sits just under halfway between $18.80 and $56.41 because peer multiples of 4.3x EV/EBITDA versus 12.2x pull up while a -34.39% free cash flow yield pulls down.

FPI fair value blends a discounted cash flow model (50%), relative valuation against sector peers (30%) and analyst consensus (20%), updated daily. How the model works →

TRACK THE NUMBER

Get notified when SMCI's fair value changes

Set your own buy price for SMCI and the app alerts you when the stock reaches it. iOS and Android.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

MORE SMCI REPORTS

This is the first FPI fair value report on Super Micro Computer. The next one follows the company's next quarterly results.

MORE REPORTS IN TECHNOLOGY

Fair Price Index is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Fair value calculations are model-based estimates and may not reflect actual market conditions. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.

FROM BULIOS

Most read on Bulios this week

Fair Price Index is built by Bulios, the investing platform with more than 200,000 investors in six languages. These are the three articles its investors read most over the past seven days.

All articles on Bulios→