FAIR VALUE REPORT

CISCO · CSCO · NOV 16, 2026 · AFTER RESULTS OF NOV 12, 2026

Cisco's fastest growth in 15 years made the shares cheaper. Who is wrong?

Revenue up 24%, guidance up $2.5 billion, and the stock down 6% to $95.64. The model's $96.23 says the price is right. Wall Street's $135 median says it is 41% too low. The 65% gross margin decides which.

FPI VERDICT · NOV 16, 2026

DCF 50% · RELATIVE 30% · CONSENSUS 20%

0.6%

at fair value

PRICE AT PUBLICATION$95.64
FPI FAIR VALUE$96.23
WALL STREET TARGET$131.42

UNCERTAINTY

MEDIUM ±20%

FAIR VALUE BAND

$76.99 – $115.48

PRICE VS BAND

INSIDE THE BAND

Numbers as of publication. Today's fair value and price: CSCO stock page → · How uncertainty is rated →

5 MIN READ

THE REPORT IN 3 POINTS

  • 01Cisco grew revenue 24% to $18.5 billion but the stock fell 6.2% to $95.64 on 13 November 2026.
  • 02Non-GAAP gross margin slipped to 65.6% from 68.1% as lower-margin AI hardware grew to a $9 billion target.
  • 03The FPI fair value is $96.23, near the price, while Wall Street's $135 median target sits 41% higher.

A $2.5 billion raise, a $9 billion AI target and a $25 billion loss in one day

Cisco ($CSCO) reported the quarter to 24 October 2026 on 12 November: revenue of $18.5 billion, up 24%, non-GAAP earnings of $1.40 per share, up 40%, and GAAP net income of $4.6 billion - the fastest revenue and earnings growth in more than 15 years. Fiscal 2027 revenue guidance rose to $74.8-75.8 billion from the $72.2-73.4 billion set on 12 August 2026, and the AI revenue target from hyperscalers went from $7.5 billion to $9 billion, or 12% of sales against 6% in fiscal 2026.

The shares answered with a 6.24% fall to $95.64 on 13 November, roughly $25 billion of market value. Three details explain it. Non-GAAP gross margin fell to 65.6% from 68.1%, with product gross margin down 3.5 points to 63.7% on hardware mix and memory costs. Product orders excluding hyperscalers grew 14%, after 25% in the quarter to 25 July 2026. And the guide for the quarter to January 2027 is $18.0-18.2 billion - below the quarter just reported.

The pattern is now established: Cisco beat on both lines in each of the last five quarters, and the stock fell 12.3%, 8.4% and 6.2% after three of the last four reports. The market is not disputing the numbers. It is disputing what they are worth.

RESULTS VS ESTIMATES · LAST 8 QUARTERS
REPORTEDEPSVS EST.PRICE REACTION
NOV 12, 2026$1.40+5.3%−6.2%
AUG 12, 2026$1.22+4.3%−8.4%
MAY 13, 2026$1.06+2.9%+13.4%
FEB 11, 2026$1.04+2.0%−12.3%
NOV 12, 2025$1.00+2.0%+4.6%
AUG 13, 2025$0.99+1.0%−1.6%
MAY 14, 2025$0.96+4.3%+4.8%
FEB 12, 2025$0.94+3.3%+2.3%

Cisco beat the EPS estimate in 8 of the last 8 quarters. Price reaction is the move on the trading day after the results.

A record 37.8% margin built on 2% cost growth - and a buyback 17% above today's price

Profit grew faster than sales because non-GAAP operating expenses rose only 2% while revenue rose 24%. That lifted the non-GAAP operating margin to a record 37.8% despite the thinner gross margin, and the full-year margin is now expected at about 36% against 34.8% in fiscal 2026. In plain terms: every extra dollar of sales carried less profit at the factory gate, but almost none of it was spent on new overhead.

Cash followed. Operating cash flow was $4.36 billion, capital spending $502 million, and $3.66 billion went back to shareholders - 95% of free cash flow. Of that, $2.0 billion bought 18 million shares at an average $112.38, 17% above the 13 November close. The remaining authorisation is $6.1 billion.

Two balance-sheet items deserve a look. Inventories rose 12% in one quarter to $6.38 billion ahead of AI shipments, with optics named as the main supply constraint. And insiders made 85 sales worth $63.9 million in the 12 months to 16 November 2026, with zero purchases.

Why the model lands at $96.23 while the price sits at $95.64

The FPI fair value is $96.23, 0.6% above the price - a "fair" verdict. The trailing P/E has compressed from 34.3x in July 2026 to 25.2x, and on the $5.50 midpoint of fiscal 2027 guidance the stock costs about 17 times forward earnings, the kind of multiple the market pays for a company growing 3-4% a year.

Half the model is a discounted cash flow, which prices cash, not headlines. Cisco converts a 22.3% net margin into a free cash flow yield of 3.64% - 27.5 times free cash flow - with a three-year revenue CAGR of 3.6% behind it. One guided year of 19% growth does not rewrite a decade of cash flows, especially when the extra revenue carries a lower gross margin than the base.

The peer leg points the same way: Cisco's EV/EBITDA of 18.8x sits on the technology sector median of 18.6x, while Arista's 41.7x comes with a 27.1% three-year CAGR that Cisco does not have. Only the consensus leg, at a mean target of $131.42, points well above the price. A PEG of 0.94x and a 14.5% return on invested capital are what keep the verdict at "fair" rather than "overvalued".

PRICE VS FPI FAIR VALUE · 119 DAYS TO PUBLICATIONPRICEFAIR VALUE
$127.41$101.79$76.17
JUL 20NOV 16

Over the 119 days to November 16, 2026 the share price went from $110.70 to $94.52 (−14.6%) and the FPI fair value from $85.05 to $96.23 (+13.1%). The gap moved from 23.2% above fair value to 1.8% below.

Street vs model: $135 against $96, a gap that widened as the price fell

Wall Street's rating is "buy", but the split is 37 buy, 36 hold, 1 sell - almost even. Targets run from $110 to $150 with a median of $135, 41% above the price. The three targets issued in the month to 16 November average $134.00, above the $128.67 average of the six issued in the quarter, so targets drifted up while the stock fell 14.4% in three months.

After the results, on 13 November, Bank of America kept $150 and Rosenblatt $140, while Piper Sandler cut to $112 from $125 on 22 September; Citigroup upgraded. Bernstein set $110 on 30 September. The sharpest call came on 6 November, when Morgan Stanley downgraded to Equal-weight and cut its target to $120 from $135, at 21 times fiscal 2028 earnings of about $5.70; its bull case is $150 at 25 times, its bear case $65 at 13 times. The same note estimates hyperscaler hardware earns 30-40% gross margin, diluting the company figure by about 1.8 points in fiscal 2027.

That is the gap in one sentence. The $135 median is about 24.5 times fiscal 2027 earnings - the multiple the stock carried in 2025-26, paid for the supercycle lasting. The model's $96 is about 17.5 times the same number: the sector multiple on cash flows whose gross margin is shrinking.

WALL STREET PRICE TARGETS · 74 ANALYSTS
LOW $110.00HIGH $150.00
PRICE $95.64
FPI $96.23

37 buy · 36 hold · 1 sell. FPI fair value sits 13% below the lowest Street target, the share price is below the whole range.

Three numbers before 10 February 2027: 65% margin, 14% orders, $102.35

Re-rating up requires the second-quarter gross margin to hold inside the guided 65-66% while ex-hyperscaler orders stay at or above 14%. That would support the Street's 24x and push the price back over the 200-day average of $102.35; a fiscal 2028 outlook above Morgan Stanley's gross-margin dilution path would do the rest.

Re-rating down needs less: a gross margin under 64.5%, revenue below the $18.0 billion floor, or core orders slipping to single digits. The 52-week low of $72.80 and the $65 bear case are the reference points below.

Fixed dates: the $0.42 dividend is payable 20 January 2027 to holders of record on 4 January; the next results are due on 10 February 2027, where consensus expects $1.33 per share against company guidance of $1.34-1.36 and revenue of $18.14 billion, inside the $18.0-18.2 billion guide. All three numbers arrive on the second of those dates.

BULLS SAY · BEARS SAY
BULL CASE$150.00+57%

HIGHEST WALL STREET TARGET

  • 01Bank of America's $150 target needs the second-quarter non-GAAP gross margin to hold inside the guided 65-66% range reported on 10 February 2027.
  • 02Ex-hyperscaler product orders staying at or above 14% would support the Street's 24.5x multiple on fiscal 2027 earnings and the $135 median target.
  • 03A record 37.8% non-GAAP operating margin on 2% opex growth shows the AI mix can scale, with the AI target already raised to $9 billion.
BEAR CASE$76.99−20%

BOTTOM OF THE FPI FAIR VALUE BAND

  • 01Non-GAAP gross margin fell to 65.6% from 68.1% and product margin dropped 3.5 points to 63.7%, with hyperscaler hardware earning only 30-40%.
  • 02Guidance for the quarter to January 2027 is $18.0-18.2 billion, below the $18.5 billion just reported, so sequential revenue declines.
  • 03A 3.6% three-year revenue CAGR and 3.64% free cash flow yield leave EV/EBITDA of 18.8x sitting right on the 18.6x technology sector median.

FPI FAIR VALUE $96.23 · FPI fair value of $96.23 sits near the $76.99 bear anchor and far below the $150.00 bull anchor because one guided year of 19% growth does not rewrite a 3.6% three-year revenue CAGR.

FPI fair value blends a discounted cash flow model (50%), relative valuation against sector peers (30%) and analyst consensus (20%), updated daily. How the model works →

TRACK THE NUMBER

Get notified when CSCO's fair value changes

Set your own buy price for CSCO and the app alerts you when the stock reaches it. iOS and Android.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

MORE CSCO REPORTS

This is the first FPI fair value report on Cisco. The next one follows the company's next quarterly results.

MORE REPORTS IN TECHNOLOGY

Fair Price Index is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Fair value calculations are model-based estimates and may not reflect actual market conditions. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.

FROM BULIOS

Most read on Bulios this week

Fair Price Index is built by Bulios, the investing platform with more than 200,000 investors in six languages. These are the three articles its investors read most over the past seven days.

All articles on Bulios→