FAIR VALUE REPORT
STARBUCKS · SBUX · NOV 03, 2026 · AFTER RESULTS OF OCT 29, 2026
Starbucks hit its 2028 margin two years early. Is $104 already spending it?
The quarter to September 2026 delivered a 14% margin and a 2027 guide that already sits inside the 2028 plan. At 32.6x that profit the stock prices the finish line, while traffic growth halved to 2.4% and the model stops at $72.
FPI VERDICT · NOV 03, 2026
DCF 50% · RELATIVE 30% · CONSENSUS 20%
31.0%
above fair value
UNCERTAINTY
MEDIUM ±20%
FAIR VALUE BAND
$57.61 – $86.41
PRICE VS BAND
ABOVE THE BAND
Numbers as of publication. Today's fair value and price: SBUX stock page → · How uncertainty is rated →
4 MIN READ
THE REPORT IN 3 POINTS
- 01Starbucks hit a 14.0% margin in the quarter to 27 September 2026, two years ahead of its 2028 plan.
- 02U.S. transaction growth halved to 2.4% as the average ticket rose 5.2%, so bigger bills drove the quarter.
- 03At $104.40 the stock trades 31% above FPI's $72.01 fair value, with a 3.06% free cash flow yield.
The 14% margin arrived two years early - and $104 already pays for 2028
Starbucks ($SBUX) closed fiscal 2026 with a quarter that looked finished before it began. In the quarter to 27 September 2026, global comparable sales rose 7.2%, the non-GAAP operating margin reached 14.0% (up 4.5 percentage points in a year) and non-GAAP EPS came in at $0.80 against $0.72 expected. Revenue of $9.14 billion missed the $9.22 billion estimate, and the stock fell 1.7% the next day.
The guidance is the part that reprices the stock. For fiscal 2027 (53 weeks to early October 2027) management guided non-GAAP EPS to $3.15-3.25, including slightly more than $0.10 from the extra week, and a margin of 13.5-14.0%. At the 29 January 2026 investor day the company had set a fiscal 2028 framework of a 13.5-15% margin and $3.35-4.00 of EPS, about $0.15 less once China became a licensed venture. The 2027 guide is already inside that range.
At $104.40 the stock costs 32.6x the 2027 midpoint of $3.20 and still 27x the top of the China-adjusted 2028 range of $3.85. The price has paid for the best case two years ahead of schedule. Fiscal 2026 net earnings of $2.53 billion remain 33% below the $3.76 billion earned in fiscal 2024, when the shares traded at $97.49.
| REPORTED | REVENUE | VS EST. | EPS | VS EST. | PRICE REACTION |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OCT 29, 2026 | $9.1B | −0.9% | $0.80 | +11.1% | −1.7% |
| JUL 29, 2026 | $9.3B | +1.6% | $0.85 | +28.8% | +1.6% |
| APR 28, 2026 | $9.5B | +4.0% | $0.50 | +16.3% | +8.4% |
| JAN 28, 2026 | $9.9B | +2.7% | $0.56 | −5.1% | −0.6% |
| OCT 29, 2025 | $9.6B | +2.6% | $0.52 | −7.1% | −1.2% |
| JUL 29, 2025 | $9.5B | +1.7% | $0.50 | −23.1% | −0.2% |
| APR 29, 2025 | $8.8B | −0.8% | $0.41 | −16.3% | −4.6% |
| JAN 28, 2025 | $9.4B | +0.9% | $0.69 | +1.5% | +8.6% |
Starbucks beat the EPS estimate in 4 of the last 8 quarters. Price reaction is the move on the trading day after the results.
Traffic growth halved to 2.4% - the ticket did the work
The engine changed between two quarters. In the quarter to 28 June 2026, U.S. comps grew 7.9% on transactions up 4.2% and ticket up 3.6%. In the quarter to September, U.S. comps grew 7.7%, but transactions slowed to +2.4% while the average ticket jumped +5.2%. International transactions fell 2.8%. June was about more customers; September was about bigger bills.
The fiscal 2027 plan leans the same way. North America comps are guided to about 4%, roughly half the September pace, with pricing to stay below consumer inflation. About 250 company-operated North America stores closed in September 2026, taking the regional count down 1% to 18,176, and revenue will trail comps for the first three quarters of fiscal 2027 as a result. Of about 1,200 net new stores planned for the year, only 90-100 land in North America, against the investor-day ramp toward 400 U.S. company-operated openings a year by 2028.
Why the model stops at $72: a 3.06% cash yield against 24.5x EBITDA
The FPI fair value is $72.01, which puts the stock 31.0% above fair value. The DCF half of the model lives on cash, and the cash is thin for a $119 billion company. In fiscal 2026 operating cash flow was $4.99 billion and capital spending $1.26 billion, leaving about $3.72 billion of free cash flow. Dividends took $2.82 billion of that, 76%. Fiscal 2027 adds about $1 billion of buybacks and lifts capex to roughly 5% of revenue, near $1.9 billion. Cash returned plus cash invested would then exceed what the business generates, with $13.3 billion of debt and a $7.67 billion shareholders' deficit on the balance sheet. A free cash flow yield of 3.06% is the kind of input that holds a DCF down.
The peer half pulls the same way. Starbucks trades at 47.1x trailing earnings and 24.5x EV/EBITDA (enterprise value to operating profit before depreciation), against restaurant-industry medians of 25.2x and 11.9x. McDonald's costs 21.4x earnings with a 31.7% net margin; Starbucks earns 6.7% on each dollar of sales. $72.01 equals 26.5x fiscal 2026 non-GAAP EPS of $2.72 and 22.5x the fiscal 2027 midpoint, roughly the industry multiple on fiscal 2027 profit. A return on invested capital of 11.5% against a 6.8% median is what keeps the number from falling further.
Over the 120 days to November 3, 2026 the share price went from $102.11 to $104.40 (+2.2%) and the FPI fair value from $72.74 to $72.01 (−1.0%). The gap moved from 28.8% above fair value to 31.0% above.
Street vs model: $117 against $72, and the newest targets sit below the price
Wall Street's consensus reads as buy, and it rests on a tie: 28 buy, 28 hold, 3 sell. The median target is $117, the mean $117.27, the range $105-130. The mean sits 62.9% above the FPI fair value, and even the lowest target is 45.8% above it. $117 is 36.6x the fiscal 2027 midpoint. The Street is capitalising the 2028 framework on a forward multiple that assumes margins climb to 15%; the model's 50% DCF weight sees cash flow that already fails to cover dividend plus buyback.
The direction of travel is telling. The two targets of the last month average $104, below the share price: Guggenheim at $103 with a Neutral rating on 2 November 2026 and Mizuho at $105 on 23 October, against Deutsche Bank's $126 from 30 July. Four banks reiterated ratings on 30 October without lifting targets. Insiders lean the same way: the International CEO sold shares four times between 5 August and 20 October 2026 at $94.76-105.99, and the 12-month tally is 14 insider sales against 1 purchase. The fiscal 2027 EPS guide beat the Street's $3.14 expectation by a cent at the low end, which is not the kind of margin that lifts targets.
28 buy · 28 hold · 3 sell. FPI fair value sits 31% below the lowest Street target, the share price is below the whole range.
What moves $104 toward $72 or $117: three numbers before 27 January 2027
Up: U.S. transactions hold at or above 3%, North America comps beat the 4% guide, the margin lands at the 14.0% top and EPS tracks toward $3.25. That keeps a 36x multiple and the $117 target alive, because the 2028 range of $3.85 would come into view a year early.
Down: pricing fades, transactions turn negative, comps slide toward the 3% floor of the 2028 framework and the margin stalls at 13.5%. The same $3.15 of earnings at 30x is about $95; at the industry's 25x it is about $81, within sight of the fair value.
- 27 January 2027: Q1 fiscal 2027 results (quarter to late December 2026), EPS estimate $0.75, revenue estimate $9.37 billion.
- U.S. transaction growth against 2.4%, and the non-GAAP margin against the 13.5% floor.
- Price levels: the 200-day average at $99.90, the 52-week high of $110.51, and the $72.01 fair value.
HIGHEST WALL STREET TARGET
- 01Reaching $130 needs EPS to push toward the fiscal 2028 range top of $3.85 a year early, with the margin holding the 14.0% top of the 2027 guide.
- 02U.S. transaction growth must re-accelerate from September's +2.4% back toward the 4.2% posted in the quarter to 28 June 2026.
- 03North America comps beating the roughly 4% fiscal 2027 guide would justify holding a 36x multiple, the level implied by the $117 median target.
BOTTOM OF THE FPI FAIR VALUE BAND
- 01Free cash flow of about $3.72 billion in fiscal 2026 already sent 76% to dividends, and fiscal 2027 adds $1 billion of buybacks plus capex near $1.9 billion.
- 02At 47.1x earnings and 24.5x EV/EBITDA against restaurant medians of 25.2x and 11.9x, a move to industry multiples on $3.15 EPS implies about $81.
- 03The two targets issued in the last month average $104.00, below the share price, with Guggenheim at $103 and Neutral on 2 November 2026.
FPI FAIR VALUE $72.01 · FPI fair value of $72.01 sits far nearer the $57.61 bear anchor than the $130 bull anchor, decided by a 3.06% free cash flow yield that no longer covers dividends plus buybacks.
FPI fair value blends a discounted cash flow model (50%), relative valuation against sector peers (30%) and analyst consensus (20%), updated daily. How the model works →
TRACK THE NUMBER
Get notified when SBUX's fair value changes
Set your own buy price for SBUX and the app alerts you when the stock reaches it. iOS and Android.
MORE SBUX REPORTS
This is the first FPI fair value report on Starbucks. The next one follows the company's next quarterly results.
MORE REPORTS IN CONSUMER CYCLICAL
- ABNB · Airbnb's bookings grew 21%. Its cash grew 6%. Is $187 running ahead of the money?NOV 11, 2026
- MCD · McDonald's rallied 20% on its first U.S. sales decline in six quarters. What did the buyers see?NOV 10, 2026
- RIVN · Wall Street and the model agree Rivian is worth $17. Who is selling it for $13?NOV 04, 2026
- AMZN · Is Amazon at 19x earnings a bargain, or is the P/E hiding a $42 billion cash hole?NOV 02, 2026
Fair Price Index is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Fair value calculations are model-based estimates and may not reflect actual market conditions. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.





