CarMax

OVERVALUEDKMX · NYSE · Consumer Cyclical
KMX·NYSE·Consumer Cyclical
OVERVALUED
CarMax
23.5%downside
MARKET PRICE
$39.06
FAIR PRICE
$29.87
MARGIN
$9.19
UNDERVALUEDFAIROVERVALUED
P/E RATIO
20.9x
DIV. YIELD
N/A
ROE
4.5%
MARKET CAP
$5B
FPI
fairpriceindex.com

FAIR PRICE VALUATION

23.5%downside

Updated daily

Model: DCF 50% · Relative 30% · Consensus 20%

MARKET PRICE

$39.06

FAIR PRICE

$29.87

MARGIN

$9.19

UNDERVALUEDFAIROVERVALUED

P/E Ratio

20.9x

What is P/E? →

Div. Yield

N/A

ROE

4.5%

Average

Market Cap

$5B

Mid-cap

NOW AVAILABLE

Get notified when KMX's fair price changes

Push notifications when KMX's valuation shifts. Available on iOS and Android.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

FPI RATING

2.3/ 10

Attractive valuation, but volatile earnings pattern and limited growth momentum.

Analytical data, not an investment recommendation. Updated daily.

How we calculate this ↗

MARGIN OF SAFETY

A 20% margin of safety below fair value — the conservative entry level for risk-aware investors.

$23.90CONSERVATIVE ENTRY
$29.87FAIR PRICE
$39.06MARKET PRICE

SAFETY MARGIN

20%

Below fair value

ENTRY LEVEL

$23.90

Fair price × 0.80

DISTANCE

38.8%

Price to entry level

At the current price of $39.06, KMX trades 38.8% above the conservative entry level of $23.90. This entry level represents a 20% margin of safety below the calculated fair price of $29.87 — a buffer that accounts for estimation uncertainty in the valuation model.

Margin of safety is a risk management concept, not an investment recommendation. The 20% threshold follows Benjamin Graham's value investing framework. Fair price and entry levels are model-based estimates updated daily. Learn more about Margin of Safety ↗

VALUATION HISTORY

Loading chart data...

P/E RATIO HISTORY

Loading chart data...

METHODOLOGY

How we calculate KMX's fair price

CarMax's fair price of $29.87 is derived from a blended model that combines DCF analysis (50%), relative valuation against Consumer Cyclical peers using metrics like P/E and EV/EBITDA (30%), and analyst consensus (20%). At the current market price of $39.06, KMX trades 23.5% above its calculated fair value.

DCF MODEL · 50%

Discounted free cash flow analysis based on projected cash flows, discounted at a rate reflecting KMX's risk profile.

RELATIVE · 30%

Comparing KMX's valuation multiples against Consumer Cyclical peers to determine if the stock is over or undervalued relative to its industry.

ANALYST · 20%

Aggregated analyst price targets for KMX, weighted by recency and analyst accuracy.

TRY IT YOURSELF

Want to test your own assumptions? Use our free calculators to estimate KMX's fair value with your own inputs.

LEARN MORE

Bulios

POWERED BY BULIOS

Get full analysis, financials, and AI insights for KMX.

Explore on Bulios

FAQ

What is the fair price of KMX?+

Based on our blended model combining DCF analysis (50%), relative valuation against Consumer Cyclical peers (30%), and analyst consensus (20%), the fair price for CarMax is $29.87. At the current market price of $39.06, KMX trades 23.5% above its calculated fair value.

Is KMX overvalued or undervalued?+

CarMax is currently overvalued based on our valuation model. The stock trades at $39.06, which is 23.5% above the fair price of $29.87. The P/E ratio of 20.9x is a key metric in the valuation.

What is the margin of safety for KMX?+

With a 20% margin of safety applied to the fair price of $29.87, the conservative entry level for KMX is $23.90. At the current market price of $39.06, the stock trades 38.8% above this entry level. Margin of safety is a risk management concept from Benjamin Graham's value investing framework, not an investment recommendation.

How often is KMX's fair price updated?+

We update fair price calculations for KMX daily after market close. The current fair price of $29.87 incorporates the latest market data and sector multiples.

What factors affect KMX's fair price calculation?+

KMX's fair price of $29.87 is derived from DCF analysis (50% weight), relative valuation against Consumer Cyclical peers (30% weight), and analyst consensus (20% weight). Key metrics include P/E of 20.9x, ROE of 4.5%.

Is KMX a good buy right now?+

At $39.06, KMX trades 23.5% above our fair value estimate of $29.87. The stock is currently overvalued. ROE stands at 4.5% (average). Fair Price Index provides valuation data — always do your own research before investing.

Does KMX pay dividends?+

KMX does not currently pay a dividend.

RELATED STOCKS

Fair Price Index is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Fair value calculations are model-based estimates and may not reflect actual market conditions. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.