FAIR VALUE REPORT

PLUG POWER · PLUG · NOV 12, 2026 · AFTER RESULTS OF NOV 09, 2026

Plug's $99 million profit came from its own falling shares - so what does $1.35 buy?

Plug Power booked a $99.8 million quarterly profit and the stock fell 8.7%. The model says $2.89, the median bank says $1.75. One quarter closes the gap - and it has to be the biggest in Plug's history.

FPI VERDICT · NOV 12, 2026

DCF 50% · RELATIVE 30% · CONSENSUS 20%

113.3%

below fair value

PRICE AT PUBLICATION$1.35
FPI FAIR VALUE$2.89
WALL STREET TARGET$2.80

UNCERTAINTY

VERY HIGH ±50%

FAIR VALUE BAND

$1.45 – $4.33

PRICE VS BAND

BELOW THE BAND

Numbers as of publication. Today's fair value and price: PLUG stock page → · How uncertainty is rated →

5 MIN READ

THE REPORT IN 3 POINTS

  • 01Plug's $99.8 million quarterly profit came from $192 million of paper gains as its own shares fell; stripping those out leaves a 7-cent loss.
  • 02To hit 2026 guidance, the December quarter needs $274-281 million of revenue, above Plug's record $260.2 million from the June 2023 quarter.
  • 03FPI fair value is $2.89 against a $1.35 close on 12 November 2026 and a median analyst target of $1.75.

A $99.8 million profit that the share price slide paid for

Plug Power ($PLUG) reported net income of $99.8 million for the quarter to September 2026 - 7 cents a share against a consensus forecast of a 7-cent loss. The shares fell 8.7% the next day and closed at $1.35 on 12 November, 5 cents above the 52-week low of $1.30.

The explanation is in the income statement: a $108.3 million gain on convertible notes and an $84.2 million gain on warrant liabilities. Both instruments are revalued every quarter with Plug's share price - when the stock drops, the liability shrinks and the difference is booked as profit. Strip out the roughly $192 million and the quarter is a loss of about 7 cents a share, in line with the estimate. Diluted EPS, which counts the shares those notes could convert into, was $0.00.

The operating business did improve. Revenue rose 13% to $200.6 million, the gross loss narrowed to $5.4 million (a -2.7% margin, from -68%) and the operating loss fell to $75.3 million from $348.8 million. Before any financing effects, Plug still loses about $75 million a quarter on $200 million of sales.

RESULTS VS ESTIMATES · LAST 8 QUARTERS
REPORTEDEPSVS EST.PRICE REACTION
NOV 09, 2026$0.07+200.0%−8.7%
AUG 10, 2026$-0.14−75.0%+5.2%
MAY 11, 2026$-0.18−100.0%+1.1%
MAR 02, 2026$-0.06+40.0%+23.2%
NOV 10, 2025$-0.12+7.7%−1.2%
AUG 11, 2025$-0.16−6.7%−2.5%
MAY 12, 2025$-0.21−5.0%+5.0%
MAR 03, 2025$-1.65−617.4%+0.6%

Plug Power beat the EPS estimate in 3 of the last 8 quarters. Price reaction is the move on the trading day after the results.

The quarter to December needs $274 million - more than Plug has ever booked

Full-year 2025 revenue was $709.9 million. Guidance of 15-16% growth means $816-824 million for 2026. With $542.4 million booked in the first nine months, the quarter to December 2026 has to deliver $274-281 million: 22-25% more than the $225.2 million of the quarter to December 2025, 37-40% more than the quarter just reported, and above the all-time quarterly record of $260.2 million from the quarter to June 2023.

The build-up rests on forklifts, not hydrogen plants. GenDrive fuel cell deployments reached 1,136 units in the September quarter, up 110% from 540, and the call put the December-quarter pipeline at more units than the first nine months combined, with a Walmart refresh of 2,000-2,500 units starting. The same quarter is meant to deliver positive EBITDAS - earnings before interest, tax, depreciation, amortisation and stock compensation - with net cash usage roughly flat at the $28 million of the September quarter.

Fair value $2.89: what a DCF sees in $28 million of quarterly cash burn

The FPI fair value is $2.89. At $1.35 the stock trades 113% below it - the market pays 47 cents for each dollar the model sees. For a loss-making company a DCF is unstable, because the value sits in cash flows that do not exist yet, so the number moves more than the business does.

What drives a DCF for Plug is the slope of the cash burn, not the level. Net cash usage fell from $145 million in the March quarter to $61 million in June and $28 million in September, with no shares sold through the at-the-market programme. Nine-month operating cash outflow was $320.5 million against $387.2 million in 2025, and capital spending dropped to $12.0 million from $106.8 million. A trend like that extended for a few years is what lifts a fair value above the price; today's free cash flow yield of -25.7% and net margin of -153.7% are what hold it back.

The peer lens offers no support. Plug trades at 2.5x sales, level with the 2.4x median of electrical equipment makers that earn a 5.7% net margin - Plug's gross margin is -3%. The balance sheet holds $134.1 million of unrestricted cash, $468.9 million of restricted cash and $470.7 million of convertible debt; book value is about $0.51 a share, so the stock already trades at 2.7 times its equity.

PRICE VS FPI FAIR VALUE · 120 DAYS TO PUBLICATIONPRICEFAIR VALUE
$3.04$1.94$0.84
JUL 15NOV 12

Over the 120 days to November 12, 2026 the share price went from $2.21 to $1.35 (−38.7%) and the FPI fair value from $2.89 to $0.99 (−65.7%). The gap moved from 30.8% below fair value to 26.9% above.

Street vs model: $1.50 and $3.00 for the same quarter, model at $2.89

Of 38 ratings, 17 are buy, 16 hold and 5 sell - a buy consensus in which 55% of analysts are not buyers. Targets as of 14 October ran from a low of $1.65 through a median of $1.75 to a mean of $2.80 and a high of $5.00, the UBS figure from 11 August when the stock was $2.20.

The two reactions to the September quarter pull in opposite directions. KeyBanc set $3.00 on 10 November with a Sector Weight rating. Susquehanna cut from $1.75 to $1.50 on 11 November, Neutral. Morgan Stanley's $1.20 from 14 October sits 11% below the price. The FPI fair value is 65% above the median target, 3% above the mean and 4% below KeyBanc.

The gap has a mechanical explanation. The median bank prices one quarter of execution risk and the dilution that follows a miss: the basic share count was 1.39 billion in the September quarter, up 20% from 1.16 billion, and authorised shares were doubled to 3.0 billion from 1.5 billion. A 12-month target sits where the next financing could land. A DCF looks past that quarter and capitalises the cash-burn trend.

WALL STREET PRICE TARGETS · 38 ANALYSTS
LOW $1.65HIGH $5.00
PRICE $1.35
FPI $2.89

17 buy · 16 hold · 5 sell. FPI fair value sits inside the Street range, the share price is below the whole range.

Three numbers to check before 1 March 2027

The upside case needs the December quarter at or above $274 million with positive EBITDAS and net cash usage near $28 million, which would leave year-end unrestricted cash around $106 million, plus the $62 million restricted cash release from a Texas power contract targeted for the end of March 2027. That removes the financing question for 2027 and gives the stock room to reclaim the 50-day average of $1.73 and the median target.

The downside case is a December quarter below the $260.2 million record or a return to share sales through the ATM. The 52-week low of $1.30 goes and Morgan Stanley's $1.20 becomes the reference. Insiders lean this way: 7 sales worth $846,117 against 1 purchase of $87,282 in 12 months, the largest 200,000 shares sold at $2.14 on 18 September 2026.

  • Revenue for the quarter to December 2026 against $274 million; the consensus estimate for the 1 March 2027 report is $277.9 million.
  • The sign of EBITDAS, and the operating loss against $75.3 million.
  • Unrestricted cash against $100 million, and whether the ATM count stays at zero.

A fair value of $2.89 prices a company that stops burning cash. At $1.35 the market prices one more raise. The December quarter decides which one the reader owns.

BULLS SAY · BEARS SAY
BULL CASE$5.00+269%

HIGHEST WALL STREET TARGET

  • 01The December 2026 quarter has to deliver $274-281 million of revenue, beating the all-time quarterly record of $260.2 million set in the June 2023 quarter.
  • 02Net cash usage must hold near the $28 million of the September quarter after falling from $145 million in March and $61 million in June, with no ATM share sales.
  • 03Positive EBITDAS plus the $62 million restricted cash release targeted for end-March 2027 would settle the 2027 financing question and support UBS's $5.00 target from 11 August 2026.
BEAR CASE$1.45+7%

BOTTOM OF THE FPI FAIR VALUE BAND

  • 01The $99.8 million profit came from a $108.3 million convertible note gain and an $84.2 million warrant gain; stripping them out leaves a loss of about 7 cents a share.
  • 02The basic share count rose 20% to 1.39 billion and authorised shares were doubled to 3.0 billion, so another raise would dilute holders further.
  • 03Susquehanna cut its target to $1.50 on 11 November 2026 and Morgan Stanley sits at $1.20, both below the 52-week low of $1.30 being within 5 cents of the price.

FPI FAIR VALUE $2.89 · FPI fair value of $2.89 sits far above the $1.45 bear anchor but well under the $5.00 bull anchor, because it capitalises cash burn falling from $145 million to $28 million a quarter.

FPI fair value blends a discounted cash flow model (50%), relative valuation against sector peers (30%) and analyst consensus (20%), updated daily. How the model works →

TRACK THE NUMBER

Get notified when PLUG's fair value changes

Set your own buy price for PLUG and the app alerts you when the stock reaches it. iOS and Android.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

MORE PLUG REPORTS

This is the first FPI fair value report on Plug Power. The next one follows the company's next quarterly results.

MORE REPORTS IN INDUSTRIALS

Fair Price Index is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Fair value calculations are model-based estimates and may not reflect actual market conditions. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.